April 14, 2017

The Book Is (Almost) Always Better Than The Film

Let’s settle the old age debate once and for all. When I have to choose between the book and the film, the book will always win. The book is always better than the film.  History has proven my point and for the most part, the book usually puts the film version to shame.

Here are some of my reasons why the book is almost always better than the film:

Limited Time

The author is the captain of the ship. They basically have a blank slate and can do whatever they want. While a book is edited, it is ultimately up to the author how long the book is going to be. Movies are typically between 1.5 to 3 hours so this means the book has to be condensed to fit that time frame. This leads to deleted scenes and developments being cut short which I am not a fan of.

Longevity

Now, this is not to say that film doesn’t have longevity because it does. There are definitely the classic films that you still love and watch even 20 or so years after it has been released. When I speak about longevity, I am talking about in terms of something tangible. Sure, there are DVDs and now Blu-Ray but there isn’t really a collector’s edition per say. With music, you can still find vinyl and with writing, we have the books. There is nothing like pulling your favorite book from the shelf, brushing the dust off and flipping to your favorite chapter. Books stay with you in a way I don’t think the film does.

Interpretation

With a film, we are only seeing the characters through the director (and sometimes) the screenwriter’s point of view. With a book, if 50 people read a specific story, there will be 50 different ideas about the characters and what that particular story line means. We all interpret the characters differently. Books allow for more nuanced characters, in my opinion than film. (I feel that television has more room to work with and does a much better job but we’re only talking about film here.)

So there you have it, my reasons that the book is (almost) always better than the film.  If YOU had to choose – book vs film?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Get On The List!

Get updates on great books, binge-worthy shows and must watch films. Signup now for the only list you'll ever need!

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Natalya Muncuff

Natalya Muncuff

Natalya is an Account Manager by day and writer by night. When she is not adding to her enormous book collection or stationery supply, she is somehow keeping track of 55 television shows. You can follow her rantings and occasional sparks of brilliance on Twitter @NatalyaMuncuff.
Natalya Muncuff

Latest posts by Natalya Muncuff (see all)

  • Definitely a book girl too. They just always seem to tell a more complete story. It is VERY rare that I consider a movie better than the book and I can only think of one offhand and I’m sure other would beg to differ. I’m a details girl, so I want to know everything I can know, and only the book is going to provide this information.

  • Pingback: Three Books That Should Be Made Into Movies - MariesList.com()